.png)
Whatis a profit-sharing loan?
A loan isconsidered profit-sharing when the interest rate is not fixed but rather tied to the success of the borrowing company. This means that both the amount of interest paid and whether interest is paid at all depend directly on the borrower's financial performance. Unlike a standard loan with a fixed interestrate, profit-sharing loans allow for adjustments based on the company's performance: If business is good, the lender receives higher interest payments, while in less successful periods, interest payments may be reduced or even completely waived.
Advantages of profit-sharing loans for risk investments
For companies, profit-sharing loans offer a number of benefits. Since interest payments are directly linked to the company's success, it provides liquidity relief. In years where the company is facing financial difficulties, the interest payments are lower or nonexistent, giving the company more breathing room. This flexibility can be crucial, especially when liquidity is tight, and traditional financing methods, such as bank loans, could become an additional burden. Another advantage for companies is that this type of financing does not dilute shareholders' equity – unlike equity financing, which requires issuing new shares. This allows the company to maintain its ownership structure without bringing in new stakeholders.
For investors, profit-sharing loans offer attractive returns since they are directly linked to the company’s profitability. Unlike a conventional loan where returns are fixed, a profit-sharing loan allows the investor to participate in the company’s profits. This can be particularly advantageous with young,f ast-growing companies, as their success can significantly increase the lender’s returns. At the same time, investors share the business risk: If the company underperforms, the interest payments are lower, reducing the financial strain on the company while mitigating the risk for the investor.
Risks of profit-sharing loans from related parties
Despite the many benefits, profit-sharing loans also come with risks - especially when they are granted by related parties. This includes shareholders, partners, or other individuals closely associated with the company. In such cases, companies and investors need to be particularly cautious about how these loans are treated for tax purposes to avoid unintended consequences.
The issue arises because loans granted by related parties can trigger what are known as hidden profit distributions. This situation is assumed when the loan is granted under terms that are not at arm’s length, meaning there is an imbalance between the consideration given and received. Specifically, for interest payments made to related parties, an imbalance is presumed if the interest rates deviate from the Safe Harbour Rules set by the Swiss Federal Tax Administration(ESTV).
The Safe Harbour Rules in Detail
Each year, the Swiss Federal Tax Administration publishes circulars that set out the acceptable interest rates for loans between related parties. These rates are referred to as the Safe Harbour interest rates. This means that if the interest payments on the loan fall within this range, no hidden profit distribution is assumed. Companies that adhere to these rates can be confident that they are in compliance with tax regulations.
However, if the interest payments exceed these rates, it is presumed that a hidden profit distribution has occurred. In such a case, the difference between the interest paid and the Safe Harbour rate would be considered an additional dividend, subject to Swiss withholding tax. This results in not only a higher tax burdenbut also the risk of losing the trust of tax authorities.
The Swiss Federal Court and Profit-Sharing Loans
The Swiss Federal Court has also weighed in on the issue of profit-sharing loans and confirmed that the Safe Harbour interest rates generally apply to these types of loans as well. This means that even for profit-sharing loans, interest rates cannot be arbitrarily set. Companies must demonstrate that the agreed-upon interest rates are at arm's length—that is, that they reflect the terms that would apply between independent third parties. If the company cannot provide this proof, the difference between the profit-sharing interest rate and the Safe Harbour rate is deemed a hidden profit distribution, with all the associated tax consequences.
Caution when financing through profit-sharing loans
If you are considering granting a profit-sharing loan to your own company, it is crucial to pay close attention to the Safe Harbour regulations. Any interest payments that exceed the specified rates can quickly lead to a hidden profit distribution, which can have both tax and legal consequences. Additionally, it's essential to ensure that you can justify the terms of the loan, especially when the lender is a related party. Thorough documentation and careful handling of these regulations are essential to minimize tax risks.
Conclusion
Profit-sharing loans are undoubtedly an exciting financing instrument that offers numerous advantages for both companies and investors. They provide financial flexibility, high return opportunities, and a risk-mitigated way to support companies, particularly in times when traditional financing methods may not be available or would place too much strain on the company. However, as with any financing method, it is crucial to understand the tax implications and plan carefully—especially when related parties are involved. Only by doing so can the full potential of this financing instrument be realized without risking unexpected tax liabilities.
